Five Canadian students are thrown into the magical land Fionavar threatened by a god. Each one shows heroism in different ways.
This start of the Fionavar-trilogy feels like a template mashup of Silmarillion, Zelazny’s Amber series and Wheel of Time (I know, the last one was written later) and there are people discarding it as a copy-over. But wait!
Silmarillion: mythopoeic style with all the short introductions of names, hints and titbits of ancient history and landscape descriptions. Kay helped Christopher Tolkien with editing the Silmarillion before, and this influence certainly shines through. There is the one god-like antagonist coming up. The landscape is Beleriand with Angband in the North, the Blue Mountains in the East and the Elves’ target in the West. Mix it with “Native American’s” Dalrei instead of Rohirrim and Brennin instead of Gondor and Pendaran instead of Mirkwood.
Amber series: contemporary characters brought to a mediaeval world like Amber, a world which is at the center of things.
Wheel of Time: weaving a destiny pattern.
I love all three themes and series, especially the mythopoeic aspect. I can see where others would have problems with that one, though. Probably it is a matter of taste and background.
If you haven’t thrown it away because of this style and references, you will discover richness: oh those background stories and those epic deeds!
Kay is no GRRM but some of his protagonists will suffer horribly and in epic ways and it is not certain that good will succeed. The novel is a strong contrast to Kay’s newer work which are not so fast-paced.
The characters develop, overcome their problems and we get a very deep impression how they feel and why they react in certain ways.
His world-building is good, though not original: There are real mages, interferring gods, flying unicorns. He references our world’s mythology in numerous places, like the world-tree Yggdrasil for the Summer Tree, the ravens Huginn and Muninn or the Wild Hunt from German mythology.
One complaint I have is that we don’t get a good motivation why the students choose to go Fionavar.
His writing is sophisticated and beautiful but not flowerish. You can feel how it developed in later works, e.g. in Tigana but this already is great stuff, an easy read with a good tension arc.
For more information and background, go to the author’s authorized website Bright Weaving!
Meta: isfdb. This is a copied review from GR; I’ve read it in 2014
Hmm. I’ve seen a couple of mentions of this lately. Maybe a review article on Quest Fantasies in the Tor newsletter? Anyway, you’ve convinced me to add it to Mt. TBR. Lower foothills, anyway….
Thanks for your review reprint!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That was coincidence. I searched for reviews on GR for an author that I haven’t here on the blog, yet.
LikeLike
Hmm I’ll consider giving him another chance – his Tigana was a huge letdown for me, both due to unoriginality and character development issues. Glad you enjoyed it, though!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I didn’t finish Tigana, serious letdown, but this was a 5 star read, one of my favorite fantasy novels, and the 2 other books of the trilogy are still great too.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Strange, I loved Tigana even more than this.
LikeLike
Tigana felt very generic to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ok, that sounds promising. Tigana was horrible; stilted, sexist, unoriginal and boring. And because people who loved Kay praised it so much I was always wary of trying his other books 😅 But if you’re vouching for Fionavar I’m going to give it a chance (and blame you if I don’t like it 🤣)!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Puh, then I‘m off the hook, and bormgans will be roasted 🤣
LikeLiked by 2 people
Boring, indeed, that was my main problem with Tigana.
Here’s my review of Summer Tree for a bit more convincing: https://wp.me/p1tcLv-In
LikeLiked by 2 people
Tigana was a five star for me. I fear the author just won’t suite you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We’ll see – Bart’s vouching for Fionavar so I’m going to check it out and write bad things on your blog if I hate it (just kidding! I’ll write them on my blog!) 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
GGK won‘t have imagined that he‘d ever be cause to a virtual snowball fight with reviews. 🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
What snowballs? I’m talking ion and plasma cannons here 🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
No deadly weapons on my blog. At least not in your hands. Snowballs will have to fit, maybe cotton wool balls.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah well, it was worth a try 🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you really want to, there is a homologation process before clearing. Would you kindly pass the engineering documents and a sample of each of the guns, please?
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’d like that, wouldn’t you? To get the engineering specs for my ion and plasma cannons!
LikeLike
Well, you’re the one waving them around so freely. I don’t have access to all that super-old tech anymore, considering all those antimatter projectors and dark energy pewpews around these days.
Without those documents there can’t be a proper certification. We wouldn’t to get other people hurt, now would we?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Show me your documents and after that I might show you mine. Everyone can talk! 😜
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sure, that’s open innovation. Just pass me your quantum-entangled cryptokeys and you’ll get access to the interdimensional safe.
LikeLiked by 1 person
But… You’ve already got them, don’t you? In the Schrodinger box I sent you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
You addressed this to the cat. Now, I don’t know if it’s inside or outside of the box. Shall I look?
btw, we’ll get two awesome cuties in May – Maine Coones.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nonono, the cat HAS the key! The question is, is he alive to give it to you? 😉
Now I’m jealous! Always wanted to have a Maine Coon!
LikeLike
Of course the cat has the key. It will be far easier to get the key when he’s inside the box. But the box is yet in delivery, because you addressed it recursively to its own content without a termination rule. Delivery will be processed for the next infinite number of steps, and I’ll have to wait for a while.
The world needs more cat pictures. Here are the two four weeks old cats:
The stoned one:
The grumpy one:
LikeLiked by 1 person
🤩🤩🤩
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t read either this one or Tigana. Only Kay I’ve read was Under Heaven and thought it was so-so. Not sure what to pick up by him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That is really difficult to say. I loved Tigana, but other people here commented that it was a letdown. Didn’t read Under Heaven, so I can’t compare.
LikeLike
You guys are almost convincing me to pick this one up, but the description of it sounds sooo generic. Maybe I need to be in a different mood.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s generic at first sight, but the prose and the characters are great. It just goes to show that the story as such doesn’t really matter, it is all about execution. Give it a go, I’d say.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I feel like reading a Tolkien inspired series from the 80s, but I have Tad Williams’ Memory Sorrow and Thorn already lined up. After that, maybe The Summer Tree would be nice.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I liked the Williams quadrology even better!
LikeLike
I tried to read this novel one some time ago, on the recommendation of a friend who loves it, but I soon found out it was not my proverbial cup of tea, starting with what you named as your only complaint, i.e. the lack of motivation for the characters to go to Fionavar – that was a big problem for me and it impacted my relationship with the story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sometimes, a tiny bit feels like a huge boulder.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, I see there’s already a huge discussion… I like the Tapestry a lot, for much the same reasons you mention. I only object to your WoT analogy, we might say the influence went the other way (if Jordan read Kay), with the idea taken, tortured (isn’t WoT a torture porn enthusiast’s treasure?), and “sort of stretched, like butter scraped over too much bread”.
I never read a Kay novel I wouldn’t like, even if I agree with some of Ola’s criticisms. She just lucks the sense of wonder and purity of heart needed to appreciate such gems.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Re:WoT I did write exactly that Fionavar was first, didn’t I?
And now I’m super anxious to see Ola‘s answer to your tease 🤣 Purity of heart, my ass 🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
You did, but you still used WoT as a positive reference point, and I find this distasteful 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re a WoT hater? Didn’t know that. WoT isn’t the height of literary Fantasy, but I really enjoyed it (and still do with my rereading project)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hate-read the final volumes (or rather hate-listened-to), and summed up my feelings on Re-E later https://reenchantmentoftheworld.blog/2018/02/06/robert-jordan-1990-2005-robert-jordan-brandon-sanderson-2009-2013-the-wheel-of-time-2/
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t know why WP doesn’t let me „like“ or comment your review. So, feel yourself liked 👍
Doesn’t mean that I have the same opinion. You make a couple of valid statements – like LotR ripoff, dragging plot, or plain-dumb villain – but you weighted those objections far heavier than I did. My overall rating of the series is a three star, maybe 3.5, meaning I liked it. I’m a sucker for epic scenes and adventurous landscapes that the series continuously provided. And I rather liked the Seanchan! If you tell me that I’m a bondage lover because of that, then I tell you: there’s nothing wrong with it 😎 Vanilla sex lovers might read one of those Romantasy books 🤮
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sure, I admit there were some epic scenes and landscapes… so, it comes to how we weight WoT’s strengths and failures 🙂
LikeLike
And tugging on braids and general Karen behavior
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s brilliant…
Aes Sedai – the Karens of Fantasy
and now you’re hated by the fandom 😉
LikeLike
I rather call them Karen Sedai 😁
LikeLike
(✷‿✷)
LikeLiked by 1 person